Enterprise: Tub & Physique Works operates a specialty retailer of dwelling perfume, physique care, soaps and sanitizer merchandise. In August 2021, Tub & Physique Works (previously often known as L Manufacturers) accomplished the separation of its Victoria’s Secret enterprise. 

Inventory Market Worth: $9.68B ($42.42 per share)

Proportion Possession:  6.02%

Common Price: $38.16

Activist Commentary: Third Level is a multi-strategy hedge fund based by Dan Loeb. The fund selectively takes activist positions. Loeb is among the true pioneers within the discipline of shareholder activism and considered one of a handful of activists who formed what has grow to be modern-day shareholder activism. He popularized the poison-pen letter at a time when the measure was typically needed. As instances have modified, he has transitioned from the poison pen to the ability of the argument. Third Level has amicably obtained board illustration at firms like Baxter and Disney, but in addition is not going to hesitate to launch a proxy battle if the agency is being ignored. 

Third Level initially filed a 13D on Tub & Physique Works (“BBWI”) on Dec. 8, 2022, and expressed its concern with the corporate’s govt compensation construction, its monetary self-discipline, investor communication and board composition. On Feb. 22, Third Level despatched a letter to BBWI’s board asserting that it intends to appoint a slate of director candidates for election. Third Level believes that further oversight is required on the board relating to company governance, govt compensation and shareholder rights.

Final Could, BBWI’s CEO Andrew Meslow stepped down from his place, citing well being causes. The board, chaired by Sarah Nash, named her as interim CEO. In its announcement, the corporate acknowledged that Nash at the moment served because the CEO of privately held Novagard Options, an organization that manufactures silicone coatings and sealants. As a part of this appointment, BBWI agreed to extend Nash’s annual compensation as chair of the corporate to $1,000,000 from $700,000 throughout the time she served as interim CEO. Moreover, the corporate agreed to pay her an annual base wage of $1,350,000 and a short-term efficiency incentive compensation goal of 190% of her base wage for her work as interim CEO. The state of affairs grew to become egregious when the board, as well as, awarded her $18 million of restricted inventory models on March 11, 2022. She would obtain this $18 million no matter how lengthy she served as interim CEO. In the end, she served as interim CEO for a full seven months for the $18 million.

Would this have occurred if an activist had been on the board? We do not suppose so. For instance, in April 2019, ABB chairman Peter Voser stepped in as interim CEO of ABB. He didn’t obtain any improve to his compensation as chairman and he obtained the identical wage and short-term incentives because the prior CEO and no further long-term incentive grants or advantages, besides these legally required. He served as interim CEO for 11 months and obtained complete compensation of $4.2 million, which was $3.3 million lower than the prior CEO and $1.7 million lower than the everlasting CEO succeeding him. ABB was a $50 billion firm on the time. BBWI is a roughly $10 billion firm. Additional, Voser didn’t have one other full-time job again then. For the $4.2 million, he agreed to commit his full consideration to ABB. One different factor – Lars Förberg, co-founder and managing accomplice of activist fund Cevian Capital was on the board of ABB on the time.

Third Level additionally takes subject with the truth that the BBWI board doesn’t designate Nash as an govt chair regardless that she is receiving $18 million in inventory grants vesting over the subsequent three years. Third Level believes that $6 million of compensation per yr renders a director non-independent. We’d are inclined to agree with that. Let’s take a look at one other instance. Richard Dreiling is designated as the chief chair of Greenback Tree as a result of he’s paid a wage of $1 million per yr and has inventory choices to amass 2.25 million shares of inventory on the firm’s all-time highest closing value, vesting over 5 years. Earlier than negotiating that deal, the board reached out to shareholders proudly owning greater than 50% of their inventory. The dominant theme from that outreach was that the corporate ought to do no matter was essential to safe Dreiling’s companies as the corporate’s high govt for a multi-year interval. That is simply good company governance. Having beforehand grown Greenback Basic from a $4.5 billion firm to a $25 billion firm in seven years as its CEO, Dreiling was imminently certified for this place. He additionally didn’t have one other full-time place, and Greenback Tree is a $30 billion firm. Lastly, Paul Hilal, founder and CEO of activist investor Mantle Ridge was on the board, introduced on Dreiling and led the board in structuring and negotiating this whole association.

In distinction, the BBWI board didn’t seem to succeed in out to shareholders, didn’t have an activist or any shareholder consultant on the board and appeared to enter an “arms-length” negotiation between Nash and the board she leads. That’s the way you attain an $18 million fee for seven months of labor whereas holding on to your full-time job. So, Third Level is now going to make a books-and-records request beneath Delaware legislation to evaluate the data the board relied on to justify this payout. My guess is that the assist for this resolution shall be underwhelming.

The Nash-led BBWI board is now doing no matter it might to guard itself from having a shareholder consultant on the board. And after I say, “no matter it might,” I imply the very least the board thinks it has to do to win. We regularly see this in activist campaigns at firms with inexperienced and/or entrenched boards. On this case, the board is “refreshing” its membership by including two new administrators to the 12-person board. This permits the board to proceed with enterprise as traditional, whereas on the similar time enabling it to go earlier than Institutional Shareholder Companies and argue that there isn’t a want for a Third Level consultant on the board as a result of it has been refreshed. Nevertheless, when a board has egregious company governance practices, its members are the final individuals you need to appoint new administrators. A board like this may want much more refreshment than simply two further administrators.

The corporate may argue that it obtained an approval vote of over 95% on its most up-to-date say-on-pay proposal in 2022. This vote was totally centered on 2021 pay and didn’t embrace Sarah Nash as a named govt officer. Moreover, ISS really useful voting “for” on say on pay, but in addition stated that the $18 million Nash award and her total compensation as interim CEO shall be analyzed subsequent yr.

Third Level’s Loeb popularized the poison-pen letter at a time when it was wanted. As instances have modified, he has transitioned from the poison pen to the ability of the argument. Third Level’s letter to BBWI is proof of that. Third Level has amicably obtained board illustration at firms like Baxter and Disney, however the agency is not going to hesitate to launch a proxy battle if it is not being heeded. Usually the distinction between amicable activism and confrontational activism is the response of the corporate. It’s as much as the corporate as to how adversarial this engagement will get. It’s typically tough in activist campaigns to establish who’s carrying the black hat and who’s carrying the white hat. On this state of affairs, it appears apparent. Giant institutional shareholders and ISS is not going to condone egregious company governance. If this goes the space, we consider Third Level will present the BBWI board how highly effective a very good argument is.

Ken Squire is the founder and president of 13D Monitor, an institutional analysis service on shareholder activism, and the founder and portfolio supervisor of the 13D Activist Fund, a mutual fund that invests in a portfolio of activist 13D investments.